A research perspective on whitetailed deer overabundance in the. For the benefit of other entities challenged with whitetailed deer overabundance, we describe implementation of an eab hunting program on campus lands. Plan for eventual deer overabundance problems at your new home when thinking about landscaping. Pdf ecological impacts of deer overabundance semantic. Impacts of whitetailed deer overabundance in forest ecosystems. The injury rate for hunting is lower than that of some other forms of physical recreation, such as football and bicycling. The study, mule deer and energy development longterm trends of habituation and abundance, appears in the journal global change biology and has implications for energy development planning on federal lands. Hours per harvest increased rapidly as the deer population declined requir. Prior information reduces uncertainty about the consequences. Impacts on forest health deer impacts in pennsylvania the forest nobody knows is a brief summary of severe deer impacts on forest understory condition and postforestry regeneration based upon research performed by dr. Effects of deer settling stimulus and deer density on. Elevated deer densities have led to reports of forest regeneration failure and ecological damage.
Original article evaluation of organized hunting as a management technique for overabundant whitetailed deer in suburban landscapes scott c. Investigating the environmental effects of agriculture. Pdf ecological impacts of deer overabundance steeve. In this article, we present only a small fraction of the literature on deer impacts. Deer play vital roles in the natural and cultural environment of new york and are highly valued for their beauty and grace as well as the utilitarian benefits they provide. Policies and management of overabundant deer deerlab. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure youre on a federal government site. However, the abundance of deer in many parts of the state is causing increasing problems, particularly in suburban and urban areas. Geological survey to enhance the management of agricultural landscapes land cover map of the conterminous united states from early 1990s data vogelmann and others, 2001. Ecological impacts of deer overabundance city of bloomington.
Investigating the environmental effects of agriculture practices on natural resources scientific contributions of the u. Their presence influences and is influenced by other organisms that live alongside them in their natural habitat. Whitetailed deer impacts and forest management introduction the whitetailed deer odocoileus virginianus is a large native mammal that occupies most of north america and has a range extending throughout new jersey. In general, deer either eliminate or retard the growth of young trees, shrubs and herbs, allowing grasses and a few unpalatable species such as. Impacts of whitetailed deer overabundance in forest. This question has been the focus of debate in recent years among hunters, animal rights activists, and biologists. Whitetailed deer odocoileus virginianus populations and harvests of. Deer impacts in pennsylvania the forest nobody knows is a brief summary of severe deer impacts on forest understory condition and postforestry regeneration based upon research performed by dr. Within such a landscape, deer impacts will vary spatially, temporally, and among plant species, in relation to the population density of the deer herd. In addition, private landowner decisions to prohibit hunting limited hunter access to many areas, allowing deer populations to grow. Deer, as with all living organisms, play an important role in an ecosystem. The impact of 231 corstorphine road deer on woodland. Ecological impacts of deer overabundance by steeve d. Simulation of the effects of deer browsing on forest dynamics.
Pdf ecological impacts of wild ungulate overabundance on. Talk to the developer, real estate agent or local wildlife biologist about possible deer overabundance in the area. The effect of deer on woodland vegetation reflects the diet of deer as well as the ability of the plants to withstand damage. Wildlife habitat management institute mule deer odocoileus hemionus may 2005 fish and wildlife habitat management lea. Ecological impacts of wild ungulate overabundance on mediterranean basin ecosystems. Williams,1 department of forestry and horticulture, the connecticut agricultural experiment station, 123 huntington street. Thus, an understanding of settling stimulushow attractive an area is to deer in terms of foodindependent habitat. May 16, 2008 i introduced forest dynamics to a deterministic herbivorevegetation model to examine the effects of vertically stratified forest structure on the dynamics of the herbivorevegetation system, the resilience and stable states of vegetation, and the interactions between deer populations and vegetation. Habitats take a long time to recover and the committee considers we do not have time to wait in delivering the scottish biodiversity strategy. Longterm regional shifts in plant community composition are. Line graph of total counts of birds and deer take in new york state.
We recorded 257 deer harvested 6999 each hunting season on lands near campus. Specifically, we examined how whitetailed deer odocoileus virginianus abundance, reserve size, and landscape context at variable spatial scales interact to influence the impact of deer herbivory on forest understory communities in 16 indiana state parks. Williams,1 department of forestry and horticulture, the connecticut agricultural experiment station, 123 huntington street, new haven, ct 06511, usa. The scale of action needed to address deer impacts on the natural environment across scotland is a significant factor. However, the abundance of deer in many parts of the state is causing increasing problems, particularly in suburban and. Their research included large enclosures with predetermined deer. An enclosure study in penn sylvania found that high densities of deer in thinned, clearcut, and uncut stands had detrimental effects on species composition.
Proponents argue that hunting is an effective form of deer management because it will remove a number of individual deer from a. Abundant mule deer populations in the 1950s and 60s were unsustainab mule deer populations have declined throughout their range, not just in area 66 and wy tatewide fawndoe ratios have declined by 20% over the last 30 yearss fawn ratios must be at least 66 100 does to sustain populations. Deer ecology and population management hardcover may 17, 1997. Effects of deer overabundance on bird populations in the. Abstract deer have expanded their range and increased dramatically in abundance worldwide in recent decades. We investigated the potential for crosshabitat interactions to modulate per capita ungulate browse effects on forest herbaceous layers. See all 6 formats and editions hide other formats and editions. Overabundant whitetailed deer and the alteration of forested communities thomas e. We found that adult trees inside exclosures grew less than those directly exposed to deer. Overabundant whitetailed deer and the alteration of. Deer ecology and population management on free shipping on qualified orders. Pdf ecological impacts of deer overabundance on temperate and. Deer in the urban environment issues analysis and management plan for the city of golden valley october 2, 2006 golden valley deer task force.
Hours per harvest increased rapidly as the deer population declined requiring. Aug 08, 20 webster 2005 found severe and lasting impacts at smoky mountain national park to be so complete that some plants such as trilliums were unlikely to recolonize local areas on their own. Proponents argue that hunting is an effective form of deer management because it will remove a number of individual deer from a population and prevent those individuals from reproducing. Effects of deer overabundance on bird populations in the long. However, there is growing evidence that the biophysical conditions of a forest that make it attractive to deer may be a contributing factor in determining browsing levels. Today, the problem of too few deer has in numerous cases become one of too many, posing new challenges for natural resource managers. Deer of several species have increased in abundance across much of north america in recent decades. Deer have expanded their range and increased dramatically in abundance worldwide in recent decades.
This species uses a wide variety of habitats, including forests. Use of earnabuck hunting to manage local deer overabundance. Easily the most common of americas large wildlife species, whitetailed deer are often referred to as overabundant. Longterm regional shifts in plant community composition. Recent advances in population control article pdf available in animal production science 514. The focus of eab was to increase the harvest of female deer and lower herd size. Whitetailed deer are the most numerous deer species found. Plants and animals all need beneficial conditions in order to survive. Relative deer density rdd provides managers with a way to broaden their approach to issues of deer overabundance from singlespecies management and carrying capacity to multiplespecies management and ecosystems. At this carrying capacity and low immigration rates, impact of bow hunting was more variable, producing population declines ranging from 20 to 70% contingent on harvest rates. By foraging selectively, deer affect the growth and survival. Cornell university implemented an earnabuck eab hunting program to mitigate deerrelated impacts on lands surrounding its campus 722 ha in ithaca. I constructed a model based on data from field studies performed in hokkaido, northern.
Determine communitys deed restrictions, policy or plan for dealing with overabundant deer. Issues analysis and management plan for the city of golden valley. Pdf ecological impacts of deer overabundance on temperate. They inflict major economic losses in forestry, agriculture, and transportation and contribute to the transmission of several animal and human. Blacktailed deer overabundance and management orcas issues. A new longterm study finds that energy development has longerlasting impacts on mule deer populations than previously thought. Overabundance arises wherever deer have unwanted impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem. These observed longterm regional changes in community composition could reflect the action of many ecological factors including succession, habitat fragmentation, climate change, and aerial nitrogen deposition as well as deer impacts. The density of deer that is desirable in a given area is one that maximizes the beneficial effects of deer while minimizing their negative impacts. Management of overabundant odocoileus virginianus whitetailed deer populations in suburban and rural landscapes remains controversial, and deerreduction techniques in these areas are often impeded by public attitudes and safety concerns. In 1997, two comprehensive books were published on deer overabundance to help wildlife professionals understand the complex biological, ecological, sociopolitical, public, and legal issues associated with managing overabundant deer. Tremblayecological impacts of deer overabundance on temperate and. Nov 15, 2019 the injury rate for hunting is lower than that of some other forms of physical recreation, such as football and bicycling.
Seadoc will present a portion of a marine lecture hosted with camp orkila a few years ago where the consequences of deer overpopulation was discussed. I introduced forest dynamics to a deterministic herbivorevegetation model to examine the effects of vertically stratified forest structure on the dynamics of the herbivorevegetation system, the resilience and stable states of vegetation, and the interactions between deer populations and vegetation. I constructed a model based on data from field studies performed in hokkaido, northern japan. Whitetailed deer odocoileus virginianus positively.
Evaluation of organized hunting as a management technique for. Study quantifies natural gas development impacts on mule deer august 2015, by rob novak a new study by colorado state university and colorado parks and wildlife found that natural gas. Deer are also welldocumented vectors for the dispersal of nonnative exotic plants knight et al. The incidence of deer overabundance at brookhaven national laboratory may be related to impacts on the population of birds there as well. Equipment needed assessing vegetation impacts from deer. But when does a species cross the threshold from common to overpopulated. Reducing the impact of deer herbivory is currently a key forest restoration strategy white 2012, nuttle et al. Deer in the urban environment issues analysis and management plan for the city of golden valley. The ecological impacts of deer are complex and varied, but all too often it is clear that these impacts are detrimental to forest health and sustainability. This study focused on effects of the presenceabsence of deer herbivory on decomposition of leaves and roots. Evaluation of organized hunting as a management technique. Study quantifies natural gas development impacts on mule deer.
Using an uninformative prior would result in a posterior equivalent to the likelihood. Pdf deer have expanded their range and increased dramatically in abundance worldwide in recent decades. Their impact on natural ecosystems is also dramatic but less quantified. Trophic cascade effects of deer overabundance on connecticut. Blacktailed deer overabundance and management orcas. Whitetailed deer impacts and forest management nrcs usda. Finding that balance requires understanding local deer related impacts, both ecological and social, and evaluating the costs and benefits of changes in deer density. They inflict major economic losses in forestry, agriculture, and transportation and contribute to the transmission of several animal and human diseases. Our findings highlight the indirect effects of whitetailed deer on the growth of adult individuals of q. Can controlled bow hunts reduce overabundant whitetailed. Longterm study finds energy development has lasting.
The number and significance of these effects make clear that deer can tip forest ecosystems toward alternative states by acting as ecosystem. This page links to scientific studies which illustrate the negative impact of overabundant whitetailed deer on ecological health and human wellbeing. By foraging selectively, deer affect the growth and survival of many. Prior information reduces uncertainty about the consequences of deer overabundance on forest birds.
1199 770 32 1495 315 326 926 493 1479 1119 1071 970 1417 1456 1006 1337 785 1041 346 561 1029 1528 1320 1394 237 653 297 631 692 34 1296 1282 990 408 370 1362 1189 981 678 1379 950 600 1197 653 173 91 968 833 1437 571 1431